Stories, brain science and strategies · 2023

The Thumping

Behind every argument, stressful thought, and regretful act lies fear. Avoiding it isn’t about suppressing our gut feelings, but about learning to separate rational fears from irrational ones.

This book has helped me sleep more soundly, worry less about money, strengthen my influence with clients and colleagues, navigate grief, and steer clear of becoming a grumpy old man. Most importantly, it has helped those closest to me — including my children — build resilience.

Buy the book

More books

Hear from me now and then

New drawings, new thoughts and only when it is worth sending.

Nearly there

Check your inbox for an email from James Lau and confirm, and you’re on the list.

It’s on its way to . Not there in a few minutes? Look in your spam or promotions folder.

Look inside · sample pages

What lurks behind every buying decision

Be wary of sales and marketing tactics that manipulate us into buying things we don’t need.

You’re hosting an important dinner party tomorrow. The plan is to make a roast dinner with all the trimmings. It’s easy and it’s a crowd pleaser. This morning you discover the oven is broken. You need to get a replacement, fast.

You normally rely on your partner to make these types of purchases, however, your partner is unreachable on the phone. You decide to take matters into your own hands and go to the mall.

At a store, you decide which model you want, a $950 oven that looks similar to your current one, and get the attention of a store assistant who asks, “have you considered a double oven? They’re very handy when you have a big crowd.”

“I do have a big crowd tomorrow!” you say.

53

“There are two double ovens to choose from. A top Italian brand — which is on sale…”

The sticker price on the flash looking Italian oven says, “$3,500. Limited Stock.”

Not wanting to appear cheap, you put on your poker face and try not to flinch at the price.

“Or we have a basic model,” says the store assistant.

This one is $1,400.

“What do you recommend?” you ask.

“It depends on what you value. The basic oven does the job, but the Italian one gives you peace of mind, and it’s what most people choose if they can afford it.”

“Is the basic one no good?”

“It’s a great machine. It will do the job for years, otherwise we wouldn’t stock it. But in the end, you get what you pay for. We never see these Italian ovens come back because people love them.”

“I see.”

“Would you be interested in Premium Care?” asks the store assistant.

“What’s that?”

“Premium Care gets you free replacement or repair if there is a fault with the oven within 3 years. It’s $300. Which might sound like a lot, but it’s a small investment for that extra peace of mind for your $3,500 oven.”

You hesitate. The store assistant asks, “If you’re interested, I can check if we have it in stock for you. Should I do that?”

“Yes, please.”

The store assistant punches the keyboard on a computer. “I can see that there is one in stock, but let me go out back and double check it is still there. Give me a moment?”

“Sure.”

Comparing the two ovens, the $3,500 oven is a beautiful,

54

eye-catching machine. It would certainly impress my friends, and maybe even raise the value of the house!

After a few moments, the store assistant returns wheeling a large box on a trolley.

“I found one — the last one! I grabbed it for you in case someone else gets it. They’re very popular and can take weeks to order in!”

You’re conscious that the store assistant has created a sense of scarcity. Although you’re aware of this manipulation, you still can’t help but desire the oven even more now because it’s the “last” one. You feel compelled to grab it before someone else does.

“That’s lucky! Thanks for grabbing it.”

“Will you put this on your credit card or pay by instalments?”

You hesitate a little. The store assistant assumed that you have already decided to buy, but you haven’t actually said out loud that you would. It’s a sales tactic called “the assumptive sale”.

“I’m not sure,” you say, “it’s a lot of money.”

“It is. Would it help if I checked with the manager to see if I can get a better deal for you?”

“Yes, please.”

“I’ll ask, but don’t expect too much. It’s already heavily discounted, and they’re very popular. I’ll do my best. Give me a minute?”

“Sure.”

After a while, he returns with a smile. “Good news, they have approved me to take another $350 off, which pretty much means you get Premium Care for free, plus an extra $50. This is an amazing deal — I’ve never sold one at this price. The manager must be keen to make her numbers this month. Would you like to take it with you now, or would you like it

55

delivered?” The question is framed carefully to make you feel in control, but it limits your options to “take it home now” vs “delivered”, as opposed to “buy” or “don’t buy”.

“How much is delivery and how long does it take?”

“$30. About a week.”

“Oh, I need it today. I think I’ll just take it then.” The assistant has been hoping to hear these words, but the money is not in the bank yet.

“Will you pay by cash or credit card?” asks the store assistant. It’s the assumptive sale tactic again.

You hesitate for a moment because it’s a big decision. You’d like to take some time to think about it, gather more information, and consult your partner, but it feels awkward to back out now, and feel an overwhelming obligation to reward the store assistant’s service.

“What the hell, let’s do it. Credit card. Thank you for being so helpful.”

As you motion to get your credit card out, the store assistant’s phone rings. “I’m so sorry. I really have to take this call.”

As you stand there waiting, you come to your senses a little. You feel you need more time. The break gives you the courage to back out of the verbal agreement. You point to your watch, feign shock, as if you’re late for something. You mouth the words, “Sorry, I’m late, I have to go, I’ll come back, thank you,” and flee the store.

You find a cafe, sit down and reflect on what just happened. On impulse, you almost bought a double oven, spending three times more than you originally intended. How did this happen? You replay the situation in your head.

“For those special occasions when you have a big crowd…” That’s what the store assistant said. It conjured up an image of

56

a big crowd of people, aroused a fear of not being able to cater to everyone, failing to impress, and letting people down.

How often do I actually need to cater to a sizeable crowd? Maybe two to five times a year? Do I really need to spend so much more money to cover those few occasions? I suppose I could use the BBQ and the stove top rather than rely on the oven alone.

The store assistant said, “The basic oven does the job, but the Italian one gives you peace of mind, and it’s what most people choose if they can afford it...you pay for what you get.” These words aroused a different set of fears: fear of buying an unreliable machine, fear of making a mistake, fear of appearing cheap, fear of going against the crowd, and fear of going against conventional wisdom. We have a tendency to follow the choices other people make because it feels like a safer choice.

You do some research on your phone. There is no data to suggest that one brand is more reliable than the other. In fact, both products share common components — most of which are not made in Italy. The rubbers and seals are made in Malaysia, the electronics are from Taiwan, the convection fan from China, the baking elements are from Turkey, and so forth. The only thing “Italian” about the more expensive model is the brand name and the exterior look and feel.

The store assistant offered Premium Care, and you bought into it. The carefully scripted words were: “Premium Care gets you free replacement or repair if there is a fault with the oven within 3 years.”

You wonder how much warranty comes as standard? You look this up on your phone. The consumer law in your country says: “Guarantees are not limited to a set period of time. Instead, it is based on general expectations of what is reasonable. Thus, for example, if high end ovens are generally

57

expected to last over five years, then buyers have a right to replacement or repair within five years.”

This makes the 3-year Premium Care completely superfluous. Why did I fall for it? You ask yourself. Fear of buying a lemon and losing money?

It’s funny how fear causes us to latch blindly onto false assurances of safety.

At the store, you felt an obligation to make the purchase — backing out felt awkward. Why is that? The store assistant had said:

“Let me go out back and double check it is still there.Give me a moment?”

“It’s our last one… I grabbed it for you in case someoneelse gets it.”

“Would it help if I checked with the manager to see if Ican get a better deal for you?”

These gestures come across as being favours, but they’re also a set of sales tactics that makes you feel obliged to reciprocate goodwill. Owing to our tribal roots, we have an innate fear of causing disappointment, wasting people’s time and creating disharmony. For example, once seated in a restaurant, given menus and served glasses of water, we’re unlikely to walk out of the restaurant even if we don’t like the look of anything on the menu. Many of us would rather risk stomaching an undesirable meal rather than cause offence. Each time you said “yes” to the sales assistant, you felt deeper in obligation, and by the end, it felt like you’d be letting down a friend if you backed out of making a purchase.

The more time spent in the store, the more committed you felt towards completing a purchase because of a fear of

58

wasting time and walking out of the store empty-handed. You also didn’t want to appear indecisive.

It’s thanks to your fear of getting ripped off, fear of making a poor decision, and fear of having to explain to your partner your actions that gave you the courage to back out.

You search online to see if there are better deals. There are literally hundreds of models to choose from. You find a small oven on sale for only $900. It seems like a good deal, but you’re unsure. You spend another twenty minutes looking for alternatives and come up with a shortlist of six models. You dig deeper into the features of each model, but it’s difficult to make comparisons because they use jargon such as “3D” and “Cyclonic technology” — whatever they mean. After another twenty minutes, you’re no closer to deciding. You wonder if you should look to purchase something second hand? Procrastination leads to more lost time. To add complexity to the problem, none of the online options will deliver an oven in time for your dinner party tomorrow.

You take a deep breath. With the luxury of time, and free from the pressure of the store assistant, you make a list of fears that you might harbour: fear that cheap ovens might break down (especially when you need it most); fear that your friends will think less of you for buying a cheap oven.

A part of you wants to give in and go back to the store to buy the Italian model, but you decide to embark on a thought exercise: what if I had no choice but to purchase a cheaper one online? You reason that if the cheaper oven breaks down prematurely, you can always return it under warranty. There is no evidence to suggest the store’s Italian model is more reliable. Your friends aren’t the kind of people that will judge you based on what oven you own. It’s more likely that no one will notice. For tonight’s dinner party, you could easily cook something else, using the BBQ and the stove instead of the oven.

59

The thought exercise helps you overcome your irrational fears. You purchase a $900 oven online, and in doing so, save your family over $2,000!

Feeling pleased with yourself, you can’t help but wonder: In what other ways are we paying too much money because of our irrational fears?

60

Long-term rut

It’s OK to experience apprehension, inertia, irritability and insecurities. It becomes a drag when others have to deal with it over a long period.

Your husband is a good man, but he is stuck in a rut, and you’re sick of it.

A few years ago, his employer made him redundant from a thankless, high-pressure job. Rather than look for another job immediately, he took a few weeks off to steady himself, which made sense to you at the time because he had become a bit of an emotional wreck working at that company. Unfortunately, it took him a long time to get back on his feet (eight months all up). The experience was awful. He sent resumes to multiple contacts, all people he thought he could count on. He responded to hundreds of advertisements, jobs he thought he’d be qualified for, only to receive umpteen rejection letters, or worse, not hear at all. Each let-down drained his confidence.

254

It got to a point where you stopped enquiring about his progress to save him from the humiliation. When he finally did land a role, it was one that was beneath him, but he felt compelled to take it anyway.

It is now approaching three years since he started that job, and unfortunately, he has been stuck in the same role. There has been very little opportunity to grow. His boss keeps overlooking him for promotions, favouring those, apparently, more adept at office politics than actual work. Your husband stays on the lookout for better jobs, but there haven’t been many on account of the economy.

You thought your husband was difficult to live with when he was out of a job, but it’s even worse now that he’s stuck in this job. He is crabby all the time, critical of everything, but does nothing to change anything. He regularly antagonises and belittles you, saying things like: “Are you blind? It’s right in front of you!” and “I can’t believe you did that again. You really are a slow-learner.” You don’t let it get to you because it’s obviously an inferiority complex. He’ll come out of his rut, you reassure yourself.

His negative attitude and complacency affect you. You’re not going anywhere on weekends like you used to. Having to share a life with him means you spend your entire evening, every evening, being drawn into TV shows you wouldn’t otherwise watch, drink more than you normally would, and both of you put on weight.

There is often a cloud over you when he’s around due to the inferiority complex. You’re sick of being his punching bag.

To get him out of a rut, you leave motivational books scattered around the house. You avoid criticism, and give positive reinforcement, praise any signs of progress, no matter how paltry.

Your husband picks up one of the more cheesy motivation

255

books. These self-help gurus can be very persuasive. It convinces him that the key to everything is having the right attitude, which in your view isn’t the complete picture, but who are you to argue if it brings about change?

One day, in an argument with you, he inadvertently quotes from the book: “You need to break out of a rut, stop being in denial, stop making excuses and blaming others, and take responsibility for your own life.”

It’s a cliched message, and ironic that it’s directed at you and not himself, but again, who are you to argue if there is a chance he applies it? The book inspires him to make many resolutions, much to your relief. He gets into an exercise routine, connects with old friends, and sets himself the challenge of being promoted at work or to find a better job by the end of the year. The book emphasises the importance of finding one’s purpose, which your husband decides is “to work in service of others”, whatever that means. Encouraged by the book to get in touch with his passions, your husband decides he wants to restore an old sailing boat, apparently a childhood fantasy. You are supportive of anything that gets him out of the house, so together the two of you spend your weekends driving up and down the coast looking at old boats. One day, he comes across a deteriorated wooden ketch, one that is badly in need of love and deep pockets. Your husband falls in love with it at first sight, dreams of reviving it back to its former glory, so you strike a deal with the seller, pay in cash, and tow it home.

The boat takes up three quarters of your backyard. Your husband doesn’t start work on it straight away. He says he has a lot of research and planning to do first, plus he doesn’t have the right equipment. You often find him standing at the back window, staring at his project, thinking about what work needs to be done, replaying the steps repeatedly in his head,

256

adjusting the sequence, but not doing any actual work. He’s afraid of making a start, afraid of making a mistake.

A few months pass. Something bad happens to your husband at work, which really upsets him, so much so that he refuses to talk about it. The episode causes him to revert to his old crabby self: frustrated, angry, critical, anxious and stressed. “I thought my last employer was bad,” he says, “but these guys are even worse. I can’t believe how badly they treat people.”

A week later, your husband proposes to quit his job.

“Have you found another job?” you ask.

“No,” he says, “but according to the book I’m reading, I must turn ‘should’s’ into ‘must’s’.”

“What does that mean?”

“Well, I keep saying things like, I should follow my dreams, I should spend more time with the kids, I should support your career, I should start work on the boat.”

“You should do all those things.”

“No, not ‘should’, ‘must’. I must follow my dreams, I must spend more time with the kids, I must support your career, I must start work on the boat. The book says I must face my fears, which I’ve worked out to be: fear of letting you down, the fear of not being a good provider, fear of losing momentum in my career, fear of not being able to get a job again. I need to let go of these fears. They are so called ‘limiting thoughts’. The book says I must be open to change, to invest in myself, and look after my mental and physical health.”

“That’s a lot of self knowledge,” you say. “I’m totally supportive of what you want to do. Is this a permanent change? Like, will you become a boat builder slash family man from now on?”

“You’re asking me to give you certainty about the future. The book says, ‘We must embrace the fear of the

257

unknown...only by letting go of the future can we truly enjoy the present.’”

You feel somewhat relieved. It’s unkind to think of it, but you hope your husband might get off your coat tail for the first time in decades. You’re excited by the prospect of change, to see him tackle his dreams, find his purpose, unshackle himself from a job that is sucking him dry. And you’re quietly excited by the thought of having him pick up the slack at home, deal with the kids, do the grocery shopping, etc.. You even allow yourself to dream, “Wouldn’t it be nice to finish work and be surprised by a home-cooked dinner once in a while!”

Your husband hands in his resignation, and, as if to prove a point, takes on his new purpose with fervour. He cooks, he cleans, he is engaged with the kids; he treats you like a queen; and he makes a start on the boat project, buying a whole heap of equipment and supplies. The lawn in the backyard might be brown, but at least it’s looking more like a working workshop now.

A couple of months pass. You notice the initial enthusiasm and standards decline, which is understandable: as everybody knows, home duties can be draining when they beckon you all day every day. The satisfaction that comes from cleaning is short-lived when kids undo the work in the blink of an eye. He has discovered that as much as he loves the kids, there is a point at which too much time with them can be too much. You try to create a better balance by taking the kids out, giving him room to work on his boat, or just be in his own mind.

A few weeks on, you notice an uptick in how much time your husband spends staring at screens. He’s watching TV, trawling online second-hand stores for boat supplies, trying to create a following on social media, and playing online games. In moderation, you feel that these are harmless ways to relax, connect with friends, learn something new or save

258

some money, but it’s clear he’s distracted from his purpose. You’re not sure what to say because you don’t want to sound like his mother. A magnanimous view is that he isn’t wasting time, the distraction and hiatus from his purpose is a necessary step towards something greater. A less magnanimous view is that he’s hooked on screens. The digital world gives him a sense of progress, the impression that he matters, the illusion that he is connecting with others, and that the savings from shopping at online flea markets are material. In reality, the in-game badges, the social media likes, the bargain deals are hollow rewards: they are inadequate surrogates for activities that would give him genuine fulfilment, such as creating deep bonds with people, making the lives of others better, mastering new skills, creating or fixing things, or engaging in self-care activities such as exercise. What concerns you most is not the waste of time, it’s the fear that the distractions do nothing for his confidence and sense of self-worth.

“How’s the boat restoration going?” you ask, knowing full well that it isn’t going anywhere. “What are you going to work on next?”

“I don’t know,” he says. He takes a moment to reflect on it, then goes into a ramble about bulkheads, bilges and bulwarks, none of which you understand.

You cut in, “It has been wonderful having you look after the kids, I mean, they’re flourishing. I’m also really grateful that you’re supporting my career. I can’t thank you enough for that.”

“But?”

“But I wonder if it’s time we support you now? What can we do for you?”

“I don’t know. I suppose I should…are you trying to say I should go get a proper job?”

259

“No, that’s not what I’m saying. You should do what makes you happy.”

“And what do you think that is?”

“I don’t know.”

He’s in a rut, too deep in it to see it, and you’re too afraid to point it out for fear of offending him. On the outside, it looks like laziness, at least that’s what your father says behind his back, but you know better. It’s a lack of confidence. He procrastinates for fear of making bad decisions, avoids action for fear of making mistakes, looks over his shoulder for fear of being judged and cannot back himself for fear of bad things of the past happening again.

The motivation book perpetuates the fallacy, “Being stuck in a rut isn’t a physical state or the result of your circumstances. It’s a state of mind.” Given that your husband has tried and failed to get out of the wrong mindset, he now carries the additional burden, “I must not have enough mental strength” (of course, without saying it out loud or admitting it).

Fear explains the despondency, complacency, and the need to escape into an online world. He’s back to his old negative self, often irritable, flying off the handle easily, critical and quick to put everyone down. He seeks refuge in food, alcohol, TV and gaming to make him feel good; he has a gluttonous appetite for sex, demanding submission inside and outside the bedroom, often humiliating. If he can’t dominate his mind, then he has to dominate other aspects of his life, including you. All the while, he is indecisive, unsocial, and unproductive. You often take the kids to social events and on road trips without him.

The boat, unloved and decaying, is a giant monument of the state of his ego. Your household lives in its shadow, day and night.

260

A year on and still no change. Now the two of you fight often. You’re sick of making excuses for him. Sick of taking his abuse and being his punching bag. You can’t understand why he is content to do nothing, accomplish nothing, be nothing. He doesn’t understand why you’re always on his back, why you have to put so much pressure on everybody, and why you can’t be more content. You’re unhappy. He is sapping your energy and being a poor role model for the kids. You feel people should take responsibility for their own lives. He needs to take responsibility for his, and you need to take responsibility for yours. And that’s when you make a deeply sad but liberating decision: it’s time to cut him loose.

If the husband were to analyse his fears, he might produce a fear matrix like the one to follow.

Most self-help books believe that this is all that is needed: an insight and a new mindset. I don’t believe this at all. Even if the husband were to come up with the fear matrix himself, albeit constructive, it’s unlikely to be enough to pull him out of the quagmire of a long-term rut, or keep him out of it for very long. So much of his negativity is hard-wired into his attitude and mental processing. It would be like asking a long-term drug user to turn their life around after a weekend retreat — it takes more than an insight and a new mindset. What we’re asking people to do is to heal their ‘fear-injured’ mind. We will cover this in chapters 7 and 8.

261

Buy the book

21 sample pages. Swipe or use the arrows, and tap a picture to see it full size.

Full size · scroll to see it all

The Thumping

by J.S. Lau

In Australia

A$34, posted free or collected in Bathurst. Choose how many at checkout, and add my other books if you like.

Continue to checkout

Order by 4 December for Christmas.

Outside Australia

Buy it from Amazon in your country: